My Review Of He Said She Said By Erin Kelly

Written by Margaret James in Books on 27 May 2018 | Views: 48

My Review Of He Said She Said By Erin Kelly

Recent graduate and astronomy fanatic Kit has fallen in love with Laura, who is the kind of smart, beautiful and clever girl he’d have thought would be forever out of his reach. 

But – amazingly – Laura falls in love with Kit, too. 

Kit is somewhat obsessed by eclipses and, inspired by his enthusiasm, Laura agrees to join him at the Lizard in Cornwall to witness her very first total eclipse of the sun. As the moon begins to cover the sun, Laura hopes to be enthralled. But clouds make this particular eclipse a far from perfect experience for Laura, and what happens next dismays her even more. She and Kit stumble across a couple having energetic sex in the half-light, and Laura is convinced the girl was being raped.

The man – Jamie – insists the sex was consensual, then he disappears into the crowd of eclipse-watchers. The girl – Beth – seems too traumatised even to speak, but later she insists she was brutally raped. When Jamie is caught and the case comes to trial, Laura is subjected to a punishing examination by the barrister acting for the accused, and she begins to have doubts. What if Jamie is telling the truth? What if he is innocent and the admittedly rough sex Laura witnessed was consensual? But then, goaded by Jamie’s counsel and feeling a sisterly affinity with the apparent rape victim, Laura tells a lie. A lie that could land her in prison and ruin her life.

She’s not the only one who is lying. As the story unfolds, it appears several other people have something to hide. 

The rape victim – that’s if she was a victim – showers Kit and Laura with gifts and gratitude one minute, but then loses it as she storms out of their lives forever. Or does she? Kit and Laura decide Beth is deranged and they become so afraid of what she might do that they change their names. But Beth knows Kit and Laura are committed eclipse-chasers. It won’t be too difficult to predict where they might be found anywhere in the world, whenever she decides it’s time to find them – and harm them? But they were on her side. Why would she want to harm them? 

The novel asks how far apparently ordinary people will go to keep a secret, what they are prepared to believe about themselves and about other people, and how much preserving appearances matters. 

Honesty is an overrated virtue – discuss!

This is a story that will keep you awake into the small hours.


Support Reviewspot by browsing the products below


Like this post? Share it with your friends

Related Articles

CLARITY -An all natural voice spray

Clarity Voice Spray

Available in great tasting Elderberry or Honey and Lemon flavours.

Directions for use:

Shake before use. Spray into mouth. Use as often as required... Suitable for vegetarian use.


Water, Glycerine, Aloe Vera, Flavour of choice (Elderberry Juice or Honey* Lemon juice)

Rose Cider Vinegar* and natural flavours* (extracts of liquorice, ginger, sage, thyme, rosehip, elderflower)

*organic ingredients used.

Made in the UK.

Give your voice clarity

Available to buy from Amazon in flavours Elderberry and Honey and Lemon

Our goal is to provide our singing community with quality products and resources to help get the most from their singing.

Over 215 FREE videos too, including singing lessons, scales, breathing exercises etc.

Subscribe below


Three uplifting and spellbinding escapist historical romances.

Available on Kindle to buy from Amazon

Quizspot, a world of quizzes at your fingertips!

Why not test your knowledge and have

some fun at the same time?

Click here to go to website.

Creative Writing Student Handbook - Margaret James

Amazon review: a wonderful book, full of practical, useful tips.

If you're thinking about doing some creative writing this winter,

our 5* handbook will inspire you and give you confidence.

Available to buy from Amazon

The Final Reckoning

The Final Reckoning is an atmospheric, twisty thriller set in the peaceful (or maybe not so peaceful) Herefordshire countryside.

When Lindsay Ellis was a teenager,  he stumbled across the dead body of her boyfriend Simon’s father, who had been battered to death.

Someone in the village knows who murdered Simon's father, and why.

Does the actual killer suspect Lindsay also knows the identity of the murderer, and is Lindsay now in great danger, too?

Available to buy from Amazon